
Marjorie Engcoy, John Din, Amy Echeverria, and Fr. Liam O’Callaghan at the COP17 Opening Ceremony. Photo: John Din
Before travelling to the Conference of the Parties (COP) 17 in Yerevan, Armenia, I was already grappling with difficult questions: Is it worth going there? What can I contribute? Will my presence with the team really make a difference?
As the meeting unfolded and I engaged with the process, those doubts took a back seat. I introduced myself to new faces, made new friends, built networks, organised our side event, helped others, participated in various activities and press conferences, and joined one working group as an observer.
During the conference, I met with representatives from different faith groups to meet the Executive Secretary of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). For a first-time attendee at a global meeting, the experience was fruitful, affirming, and deeply inspiring. Thanks to the tireless efforts of numerous faith representatives across previous COPs, faith is slowly re-entering the conversation about biodiversity loss. When asked about support from faith groups, the Executive Secretary responded promptly, noting that these groups have brought ethics and spiritual values back into the conversation about conservation, sustainability, and biodiversity protection and restoration.
The Faith for Biodiversity group continued to advocate for greater space and opportunities to bring spiritual values into this extremely complex challenge. One specific request was for the CBD Secretariat to make an intentional effort to create a dialogue space between faith and science. This request was warmly accepted, and we look forward to the ongoing emergence of the faith dimension in these negotiating spaces - moving from a purely scientific discourse to a faith-inclusive conversation.
Having accompanied the Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities (IPLC) caucus during the second week of COP 17, one can see that spirituality - their relationship with the divine - is so integral to their worldview that it cannot be separated from their daily lives. It permeates everything: their relationships with each other and with the natural world.

John Din (standing, wearing a light yellow sweater) with other members of the Faith for Biodiversity group after their meeting with the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) Secretariat. Photo: John Din
Isolating the faith dimension from daily life produces a compartmentalised spirituality - an inconsistency between professed faith and actual behaviour. This is the danger if the model of revival we bring to the COP conversation is a faith devoid of lived reality. Bringing faith back to COP 17 cannot remain an exercise in abstract values and ethics; like the lives of Indigenous peoples around the world, it must be embodied. Only when the faith dimension is embodied and seen as part of an interconnected whole can we find genuine possibilities and hope in addressing the complex realities of biodiversity loss and climate change. When we recognise that biodiversity loss is not an isolated problem, but rather - as Laudato Si’ reminds us - a manifestation of “A certain way of understanding human life and activity - the dominant technocratic paradigm - has gone awry, to the serious detriment of the world around us”, we become more realistic. We see that these problems are deeply interconnected. Consequently, our individual responses are not isolated efforts but essential chapters in a collective narrative currently under construction.
While history shows that international collective action can resolve complex environmental crises - such as the recovery of the ozone layer - most nation-states still refuse to recognise that only collective action can guarantee our future. Watching party delegates in action, I was often unsure whether they were simply unaware that their narrow national interests were stalling the negotiations.
Civil society organisations (CSOs), non-governmental organisations (NGOs), the academe, and faith-based groups constantly surround the negotiating tables where delegates sit. Silent sighs and bursts of applause fill the room, reflecting the constant advances and backsliding in the negotiation text. Today, words and phrases that are desperately needed in our time are treated as "red lights" that influential, industrial and developed countries oppose at all costs. Frameworks such as a rights-based approach, the human rights of environmental defenders, gender-based approaches, and business/corporate disclosure remain highly contentious. Whenever they appear in the draft text, a long and tedious debate inevitably ensues.
Furthermore, some parties refuse to recognise the science of biodiversity loss reported by the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) - the global authority for synthesising scientific data into actionable policies. By minimising crucial reports and merely stating they "take note" of them, these parties risk driving negotiations by political opinion rather than verifiable facts.
Geopolitical agendas heavily influence these negotiations. Large nations that rely on extractive economies and territorial expansion frequently reject science-based analyses and treaties—such as the High Seas Treaty, commonly known as the Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ) Agreement—that would otherwise contribute enormously to planetary protection.
Back home, people often ask me if participating in COP 17 was worth it, or if the COP framework is still fit for purpose. Instead of answering directly, I prefer to share what people at home truly need to know: what the observers are actually doing, and why they must remain vigilant.
Biodiversity is not a simple issue; it is a matrix of complex crises. Every day, observers gather in caucuses to share updates from various contact groups and to analyse where negotiations are heading. You cannot help but appreciate the dedication of those who track these minute details to keep the process on course. COP 17 is not for the faint-hearted. It is for the courageous who are willing to stand against the odds because the dream is worth fighting for.
This courage is paired with immense creativity. I have seen the profound power of silent protests; displaying images of murdered and imprisoned environmental defenders captured the attention of every delegate in the room.
As COP 17 came to a close, the image that stayed with me was delegates seated around a massive U-shaped table, completely encircled by observers—youth, women's organisations, the academe, CSOs, NGOs, Indigenous peoples, and faith-based organisations. This image perfectly illustrates the watchdog role of civil society. In that room, the observers were silently sending a message to the parties: We cannot intervene in your debates, but we are watching you with eyes that demand transparency, truth-telling, and accountability. And we will watch you through the wee hours of the night and into the dawn of a new day.
Ultimately, this answers my opening question. The appropriate question for a COP participant is not “Is it worth it?” but rather: “How can we use our collective presence to force transparency, accountability and embody the change the world is waiting for?”
Columban lay missionary John Din lives and works in the Philippines.
Related links
- Read more from the current Columban eBulletin

